Skip to content 
Founder-led sales is one of the great advantages of an early-stage company. You know the product intimately. You can answer hard questions in real time. You carry the mission in a way no hire ever will – at least not immediately. Customers feel that, and they respond to it.
The problem is you can’t scale it. At some point, you become the bottleneck. Every deal waits for you. Every conversation requires you. And the rest of the business suffers because the person who should be running it is perpetually in sales meetings.
So you decide to hire someone to take it on. And this is where it gets genuinely complicated.
After 27 years placing people in roles like this, I can tell you: hiring a BD person to replace the founder in sales is one of the trickiest hires a startup makes. The failure rate is high, the reasons for failure are almost always the same, and most of them are completely avoidable.
Before You Hire Anyone: Is Your Business Actually Ready?
This is the question that doesn’t get asked often enough. The instinct is to find the person and fix the problem. But if the infrastructure isn’t there, even a brilliant BD person will struggle.
Run through this honestly before you start a search:
Do you have a documented sales process?
Not in your head.
Written down.
- What are the stages?
- What happens at each one?
- What does a good prospect look like versus a bad one?
- If you’ve never had to document this because it lives in your head, now is the time.
A new BD person can’t replicate what you do if you can’t articulate what you do. And if they’re left to figure it out themselves, they’ll build something different – which may or may not work.
Do you have a CRM, and is it up to date?
This sounds like admin. It isn’t.
The pipeline, the relationships, the notes from every conversation – these are the assets you’re handing over. If they don’t exist in a system, your new hire is starting from scratch with none of the context that makes your relationships valuable.
Do you have case studies, a pitch deck, and clear pricing?
Most founders can answer any client question because they know everything.
A new BD person can’t do that. They need collateral. If your pitch relies entirely on you talking it to life, it needs to be rebuilt as something transferable before anyone else can carry it.
Do you have enough pipeline for someone to work with?
This is the one that catches founders most off guard.
If your business development is entirely founder-driven and you’re the source of all new opportunities, hiring someone to convert those opportunities is a different proposition to hiring someone to generate them.
Both are valid. However they require very different people.
The Most Important Question: What Kind of BD Person Do You Actually Need?
There are broadly three types of BD hire. Most founders don’t distinguish between them – and then wonder why the person they hired isn’t performing.
The Hunter
A Hunter finds new business from scratch.
They’re energised by cold outreach, relationship building with people they’ve never met, and turning a blank page into a pipeline. They don’t need to be given a warm list of leads – they’ll build one.
If you’re in a market where your business isn’t well known yet, or where the buyer relationship needs to be built before any sale can happen, you need a Hunter. They tend to be driven by autonomy and ownership. Give them a target and get out of their way.
The question to ask yourself:
Do we have a product that someone will buy from a stranger, or does it require a warm relationship first?
If the latter, a Hunter needs time to build that pipeline before you’ll see results. That means revenue is slower to arrive. Plan for it.
The Converter
A Converter takes warm leads and turns them into clients.
They’re skilled at the sales conversation, at handling objections, at moving deals through a pipeline you’ve already populated. They are not typically the person to build pipeline from nothing.
If you have strong inbound, a good referral network, or regular leads from marketing, a Converter is often the right first hire. They can be operational quickly because they’re working with material you’ve already created.
The risk:
If your inbound dries up, or if your pipeline was entirely founder-generated and built on personal relationships that don’t transfer, a Converter will underperform – and it won’t be their fault.
The Hybrid
Some people can do both.
However be careful here.
There’s a real tendency in startup hiring to write a brief that requires someone to both build pipeline from scratch and convert it at pace – plus manage existing accounts, represent the company at events, and build the function from nothing.
That’s four jobs.
Even the best BD person will fail at that brief.
If you genuinely need a Hunter-Converter hybrid, be honest about which is the primary need, and hire for that first. The secondary capability is a bonus, not the baseline.
Does Industry Knowledge Matter?
This is genuinely context-dependent. Let me give you both sides.
The case for industry knowledge: in highly technical or regulated sectors, the ability to have a credible peer-level conversation with a potential client matters.
If you’re selling to CTOs or technical buyers, someone who doesn’t understand the product domain will struggle to get past the surface-level conversation. Industry knowledge also shortens the ramp time significantly – they know the players, the language, the pain points.
The case against prioritising it: industry knowledge is learnable.
Sales instinct, the ability to build relationships quickly, and genuine curiosity about the problem you’re solving – these are much harder to train in.
I’ve seen founders hire someone with the perfect CV and exactly the right sector background who was a poor cultural fit and had no real drive. It didn’t work. And I’ve seen founders take a chance on someone from an adjacent industry who had brilliant commercial instincts and was closing deals within ninety days.
My honest view: if your buyer is highly technical and the sales cycle requires deep domain credibility, you need industry knowledge.
If your buyer is a generalist or a business decision-maker, it matters less.
What matters more in most cases is whether the person understands how to build trust and move a deal forward.
The Transition Period – Often the Part That’s Overlooked
Even when the hire is exactly right, the handover from founder-led sales to hired BD is a process, not an event.
Plan for a period – typically three to six months – where you’re genuinely working alongside them rather than handing off and stepping back.
They need to shadow your conversations, understand the relationships you’re passing to them, and develop their own credibility with your existing contacts before they can carry those relationships independently.
This period also protects you. If something goes wrong with a key account during the transition, you’re still close enough to catch it.
The founders who struggle with this transition tend to be the ones who hand over completely, too fast, because they’re desperately trying to free up their own time. Understandable – but the urgency is exactly what makes it go wrong.
Structuring the Role to Give Them a Chance
A few things worth building into the role design from the start:
Set clear targets, but realistic ones.
If you’ve been doing this as a founder with twenty years of relationships and deep domain knowledge, your numbers aren’t the benchmark for someone starting in month one. Build in a proper ramp period with milestones that reflect the reality of the pipeline they’re inheriting.
Give them something to sell with.
Invest time upfront in making sure the pitch deck, case studies, pricing, and proposal templates are genuinely good. These aren’t nice extras – they’re the tools of the job.
Be honest about what you’re handing over versus what you’re keeping.
Some founder relationships will never transfer – that’s fine.
Be clear about which accounts stay with you and which are in scope for the new hire. Ambiguity here causes real problems.
And check in regularly in the first 180 days. Yes 180 days. There’ll be. ahoneymoon period about days 45-90 and you don’t want to get that ‘I haven’t hired the right person’ at that point. It takes a good solid 180 days to really ramp your first BD person up. Your second BD person will not be 180 days – more like 120-150 days and so on.
These first 180 days are not about micromanaging – to stay close enough to see what’s working, what isn’t, and what support they actually need.
If you’re thinking about this hire and want a conversation before you start, a Hiring Health Check is the right place to begin. We’ll look at what you actually need, what kind of person fits your stage, and whether you’re ready to make this hire yet.
Get a free Hiring Health Check
AUTHOR BIO
Helen Wingrove-Sanders has 27 years of recruitment experience and is the founder of HFBAC. She works with bootstrapped and founder-led UK businesses using her Chemistry First methodology – the belief that the right hire isn’t the best CV in the pile, it’s the right person for this team, at this stage. Find her at hfbac.com.
